From 2017-2022, Sarah co-hosted the Pilot House podcast with Strangely Doesburg. They watched the pilot episodes of popular TV shows, most of which they’d never seen, and tried to predict where the show was going from there. Over 70 episodes are available to listen to on pilothousepodcast.com, Apple Podcasts, and your favorite podcatcher!

Guest Appearances
Sarah has also been so fortunate as to be invited to appear as a guest or have music featured on a number of podcasts. If you’d like her to lend her excellent radio voice and charming presence to your podcast, shoot her an e-mail.
- Advent Calendar House: A Rugrats Passover (June 2023)
- Only Three Lads: Top 5 Soundtrack Albums (February 2022)
- Filkcast: Episode 131 [song] (February 2022)
- Strangely & Friends: Strangely Doesburg and the Troglodyte Experiment (September 2020)
- Strangely & Friends: Sarah Shay Would Like to See the Menu (April 2020)
- Ace Audio Archive: “Maybe It’s You” [song] (February 2020)
- Advent Calendar House: Shalom Sesame: Chanukah (December 2019)
- Strangely & Friends: The Wizard of Speed and Time (May 2019)
- The Tales of Sage & Savant [song] (February 2019)
- Advent Calendar House: Lamb Chop’s Special Chanukah (December 2018)
- Obsessed, with Joseph Scrimshaw: The Films of Rian Johnson (March 2018)
- Advent Calendar House: A Rugrats Chanukah (December 2017)
- Shickers in Seattle: The Mongrel Jews (April 2014) [Audio unavailable]
- The Best Pickles (December 2012) [Audio unavailable]
